If you are weighing up weight loss surgery or weight loss injections, you are asking a question a lot of people are asking this year. The two get talked about as if they were rivals. They are really two different kinds of treatment, and which one suits you depends on your health, your BMI and your medical history. That decision belongs with your own doctor. What we can do here is explain how each one works, so the conversation with your doctor is an easier one.
How weight loss injections work
The injections most people mean are GLP 1 medicines. They are prescription medicines that copy a hormone your gut releases after eating. They slow the emptying of the stomach and act on the parts of the brain that control appetite, so you feel full sooner and think about food less.
A doctor has to prescribe them, and a doctor should keep an eye on you while you take them. Most are given as an injection under the skin once a week, and the dose is usually raised slowly over a number of weeks. Nausea, constipation and other stomach complaints are the side effects people report most often. There are rarer, more serious ones that your doctor will talk you through.
The point that often gets missed is that these medicines work while you are taking them. They are designed for ongoing use. Appetite tends to return when people stop, and weight often follows. So the honest way to think of an injection is as a long term treatment, with a long term cost and regular check ups. It is not a short course.
How weight loss surgery works
Surgery changes the anatomy. In a sleeve gastrectomy the surgeon removes a large part of the stomach and leaves a narrow tube. In a gastric bypass a small pouch is made at the top of the stomach and joined to the small intestine further down. Both are normally done by keyhole surgery under a general anaesthetic.
These are permanent operations. A sleeve cannot be reversed, and a bypass is very difficult to undo. They carry the risks of any major surgery, such as bleeding, infection, leaks and blood clots, plus longer term problems like reflux or low vitamin and mineral levels. Most people need to take supplements for life and have blood tests every year.
Surgery also asks a lot of you afterwards. You will eat small portions, follow a staged diet for the first weeks, and need follow up with a dietitian and your GP at home. It is one operation, but it is not a one day commitment.
Weight loss surgery or weight loss injections: the main differences
- Permanence. Surgery is a lasting change to your body. Injections can be stopped, but their effect usually stops too.
- Risk. Surgery carries its risk up front, around the operation itself. A medicine carries a smaller risk that continues for as long as you take it.
- Commitment. Surgery means lifelong supplements and follow up. Injections mean ongoing prescriptions, monitoring and cost.
- Eligibility. Surgeons generally work to BMI thresholds and look at related conditions such as type 2 diabetes. Prescribers have their own criteria, and some health conditions rule a medicine out.
It is not always one or the other. Some people use a medicine first and later choose surgery. Some are prescribed a medicine after surgery. Doctors are still working out how best to combine them, which is another reason to get advice that is about you and not about the average patient.
What to ask your doctor
A few questions are worth taking to your GP or specialist before you decide anything. Ask which options you actually qualify for, given your BMI and health. Ask what happens if you stop a medicine. Ask what follow up you would need after surgery and who would provide it. And ask about your own risk factors, because previous abdominal surgery, reflux or a history of pancreatitis can change the answer.
Be wary of anyone selling either option as easy. Neither replaces changes to eating and activity. Both work best alongside them.
If you are thinking about surgery abroad
Some Australians look overseas for bariatric surgery because of cost or waiting times. If that is you, plan the aftercare before you plan the flight. You need a GP at home who knows what you are having done, a dietitian lined up, and a clear answer from the clinic about who you contact if something goes wrong once you are back. Our page on bariatric surgery pricing shows how costs compare between countries.
Holiday Health does not prescribe medicines and we cannot tell you which treatment is right for you. What we can do is put your questions to surgeons abroad and help you compare quotes, at no cost to you. If that would be useful, send us a message and tell us where you are up to.
Frequently asked questions
Are weight loss injections as effective as weight loss surgery?
They work in different ways and results vary a great deal from person to person. Your doctor can tell you what is realistic for you based on your BMI, health and medical history.
Do you have to stay on weight loss injections forever?
GLP 1 medicines are designed for ongoing use and their effect on appetite generally fades when you stop. How long you stay on one is a decision to make with the doctor who prescribes it.
Can you have weight loss surgery after using weight loss injections?
Yes, some people do. Tell your surgeon and anaesthetist about any medicine you take, because they may ask you to pause it for a period before an operation.
